Is ECNL better than Girls Academy?

We do not rank one above the other. Our directory lists 133 ECNL Girls clubs in 34 states and 121 Girls Academy clubs in 35 states.

Can a club be in both ECNL and the Girls Academy?

In our directory no club holds a place in both leagues.

How many clubs are in the Girls Academy?

The league says over 120 (About the Girls Academy (2025/26 season)). Our directory lists 121.

How many ECNL Girls clubs are there?

Our directory lists 133, in 34 states.

Do college coaches watch GA and ECNL?

NCAA rules define an evaluation as the observation of a player taking part in any practice or competition at any site (Bylaw 13.02.7), so nothing in the rules stops a coach watching either. Neither league is required by any college rule.

Guides

The two girls’ national leagues

ECNL vs Girls Academy: what is the difference?

The short answer

ECNL Girls and the Girls Academy (GA) are the two national top-level leagues in girls’ club soccer. They are separate: our directory lists 133 ECNL Girls clubs and 121 Girls Academy clubs, and no club holds a place in both. Each has a second level under it, the ECNL Regional League and GA Aspire. Neither league is required for college soccer, and we do not rank one above the other.

Sources last checked October 5, 2026

Pictured: Seattle U v Air Force, men’s, 2016

United States Air Force Academy · Public domain

ECNL Girls and the Girls Academy in our directory
ECNL Girls clubs	133 in 34 states
Girls Academy clubs	121 in 35 states
Clubs in both	0
States with both leagues	31
Second level	ECNL Regional League (411 clubs) · GA Aspire (148 clubs)

How do ECNL and the Girls Academy compare?

The two leagues, counted

	ECNL Girls	Girls Academy
Clubs in our directory	133	121
States	34	35
States only this league is in	Idaho, Kentucky, South Carolina	Delaware, New Hampshire, New Mexico, Rhode Island
Second level	ECNL Regional League, 411 clubs	GA Aspire, 148 clubs
Full club list	ECNL Girls clubs	Girls Academy clubs

The Girls Academy’s own description: over 120 member clubs in eleven conferences, with teams at U13, U14, U15, U16, U17 and U19; league play begins in August and ends with playoffs and national finals in June and July (About the Girls Academy (2025/26 season)). The ECNL’s site lists its competitions and clubs and prints no count of its own that we could read, so the ECNL figures here are ours.

Which league is bigger in each state?

Clubs by state, for the states with the most between the two leagues

State	ECNL Girls clubs	Girls Academy clubs
California	25	19
Texas	11	7
Florida	9	5
Virginia	5	7
Washington	5	7
North Carolina	5	5
Pennsylvania	5	5
Michigan	5	4
New Jersey	3	6
New York	4	5
Ohio	5	4
Georgia	5	3

A state’s name links to every club in that state, in every league.

This is the comparison that matters to a family, because nobody chooses a league in the abstract. You choose between the clubs you can drive to, and the table shows how much that differs from state to state.

What sits under each league?

Under ECNL Girls is the ECNL Regional League, with 411 clubs in our directory. Under the Girls Academy is GA Aspire, which the league describes as a tier two league where clubs must apply and meet specific criteria for acceptance; it has 148 clubs in our directory.

The whole ladder is in girls’ club soccer levels.

Is ECNL or GA better for college recruiting?

No rule favors either. The NCAA and NAIA manuals name no youth league, and the NCAA defines a coach’s evaluation as the observation of a player taking part in any practice or competition at any site (Bylaw 13.02.7). The Girls Academy describes regional and national showcase events throughout the year in its season.

A league puts a team in front of coaches. It does not put one player on one coach’s list. That takes a list of colleges that fit, video and an email, whichever league the video was filmed in: how to email college soccer coaches.

How should a family choose between an ECNL club and a GA club?

List the clubs of both leagues within the drive you can live with.
Watch each club’s team in your daughter’s age group train and play.
Ask each club where she would play: first team or second, starting or not.
Ask for the whole year’s cost, travel included.
Ask the coach which college coaches they have spoken to this year about their players.

Start from the clubs near you: youth clubs by state.

Q&AQuick answers

Is ECNL better than Girls Academy?: We do not rank one above the other. Our directory lists 133 ECNL Girls clubs in 34 states and 121 Girls Academy clubs in 35 states.
Can a club be in both ECNL and the Girls Academy?: In our directory no club holds a place in both leagues.
How many clubs are in the Girls Academy?: The league says over 120 (About the Girls Academy (2025/26 season)). Our directory lists 121.
How many ECNL Girls clubs are there?: Our directory lists 133, in 34 states.
Do college coaches watch GA and ECNL?: NCAA rules define an evaluation as the observation of a player taking part in any practice or competition at any site (Bylaw 13.02.7), so nothing in the rules stops a coach watching either. Neither league is required by any college rule.

How this was counted

Club counts are our club directory, built on 2026-10-05 from each league’s own published club list. A club is one name in one state. What the Girls Academy says about itself is quoted from its own site, read on 2026-10-05.

Sources

Last checked against these sources onOctober 5, 2026. Figures marked Startline are counted from the data we hold and move when it does. Rules change: check anything dated against the governing body itself.

NextFrom this guide to the app

See the youth pathway for a sample player

The demo’s youth track shows clubs by level near a sample player, with tryout pages.

Open it in the demo Or get your free target list

The demo is the real product with a sample player in it. No account, no card, and nothing you do in it is charged or sent.